In December, I wrote to you about the Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives ("HAFA") program under the Home Affordable Modification Program ("HAMP"). In March 2009, President Obama introduced the Home Affordable Modification Program in connection with his Making Home Affordable ("MHA") plan. These plans and programs represented the Obama Administration's efforts to allow borrowers who are eligible (according a specific set of standards and guidelines) to avoid foreclosure by modifying their loans to a level that is affordable and sustainable for the long-term.
Now, I write to you again to bring you some more information about this program and the potential benefits and pitfalls of this new HAFA program set to roll out in April. HAFA intends to help the homeowners that HAMP could not. Basically, if you did not qualify for assistance under HAMP, you may now use HAFA to attempt to avoid foreclosure. How? Through a short sale or Deed-In-Lieu ("DIL") of foreclosure. Seems easy enough, right? Since you can no longer pay your mortgage, the government is now incentivizing it for a buyer to come along and make an offer on your house allowing you out of your mortgage obligations while still recovering some money for the bank that owns your house. The DIL basically allows you to present a Deed to the bank in lieu of foreclosure, that means, instead of the bank foreclosing, kind of like a surrender. Now, you still lose your home, but under these circumstances, your credit will be less adversely affected and you may remain eligible to potentially purchase another home. It has been reported that of the almost 1 million borrowers who were given HAMP assistance (essentially, loan modifications) only about 67,000 (about 6.5%) were provided with a permanent solution to their problem. So that means that about 93% of the people who received loan modifications are STILL struggling with their mortgages.
HAFA is seen as a potential solution to this problem. Read the next few paragraphs and decide for yourself.
Eligibility – the eligibility requirements for HAFA are extremely similar to HAMP in that the home must be a primary owner-occupied residence with the lien originating before 2009 provided that default is reasonably foreseeable and that the owed balance is not more than $729,750 (for single family residences). Additionally, the borrower's total monthly payment must exceeds 31% of his/her gross income.
Proponents of the program are saying that it is intended to streamline the short sale process by creating an alternative situation for homeowners that HAMP could not help (even though, technically if you were not eligible for HAMP, you probably won't be eligible for HAFA since the requirements for eligibility are substantially similar). Also, this program is meant to streamline the process of a short sale in that it hopes to use the documentation submitted under HAMP (again running into eligibility questions) and also hopes to create an environment where short sales will be pre-approved prior to listing the property for sale.
Now, there are some benefits, as I see them, in the HAFA program. One certain benefit is that HAFA works to ensure that the homeowner is fully released from liability from their first mortgage and sometimes even their second mortgage (depending on the acceptance of initiatives). Also, HAFA will aim to standardize the short sale process, which anyone who ever tries to work with the government knows is not a small task. The Federalist nature of our government creates a lack of uniformity by its nature.
Also, HAFA will provide monetary incentives like relocation assistance for the homeowner, recoupment of loan servicer costs, and up to a $1,000 match for investors for allowing a total of up to $3,000 in short sale proceeds to be distributed to subordinate lien holders (on a one-for-three matching basis; up to 3% of the unpaid principal balance of each subordinate loan).
However, as a homeowner considering assistance through this program, there are things you should know. First, the property that is being listed can not be listed or sold to anyone that the borrower has a personal or business relationship with. The new owner can not sell the home for at least 90 days, the surrendering homeowner will have to list the forgiven debt as INCOME on his/her tax return, and the loan servicer will report to the credit reporting agencies that the mortgage was settled for less than full payment, which will have a negative impact on the homeowner's credit score.
